RE: why a fixed blade and why a mechanical?
You have to take some of the momentum VS Kinetic Energy discussions with a grain of salt.
Rear deployment mechanicals penetrate as well as a fixed blade and some do more damage. I've shot Slicks side by side with the Piston Points and the Piston Points (Now Trophy Ridge Undertakers)penetrated the same or better. Front deployment mechanicals may have a chance of loosing penetration as well deflecting depending on the design.