If you loved the General, you need to get the Guardian. I did the same type of test last month with almost the identical list of bows. I too had a problem finding a guardian to shoot. I ended up shooting a 2007 leftover and loved it. When the guy at the shop said the 2008's are even quieter and smoother, I immidiately started looking for one. I didn't bother ordering through the store because i knew i could find one way cheaper over the internet. I was right. Brand New 2008 Bowtech Guardian for $605 to my door. Can't be it. The only thing i needed to do is take it to the local shop and have them swap out the mods(free). Best bow i have ever held in my hands. No questions asked. Best of luck to you and happy hunting.