The statement made was more for the general casting for the show. Yes I agree that if you put most seasoned hunters at the right place at the right time you will harvest great bucks. I also agree that Stan is very excitable and each time he goes into spasims I'm waiting for the heart attack to follow. But it is the show's chemistry that I was referring to. Either alone may be good but the two of them together I believe makes the show. For example...would Lee have a show without Tiffany? I doubt it. Another example is Archer's Choice. A certain chemistry is created for the veiwership. Even Jim Shockey has been created so he may be that TV hunter that you would like to sit, have a beer with, and swap hunting stories. All of these are created characters for the show. Even characters you love to hate sell product so providing characters that each end of the spectrum is good for business. This is where I think North American Whitetail has it. Look at the posts in this thread. There is no middle ground.