My suggestion.......get another rest.

I had the same problem with a Shaky hunter. No matter how I turned the nock I got contact. I tried everything.

If you are just dead set on using the Trophy Taker why dont you try a different fletching. I used 4 inch feather which helped with the contact but I did get contact. Maybe try a shorter fletching that has a lower profile. I know Easton fletchings are a low profile plastic vane. The 3 7/8 easton vane looks about a 1/8 th of an inch shorter than my 4 inch gateway feathers.

I went back to a shoot through rest. I had to reduce the helical but if I tune my bow correctly my broadhead shoots great ( same point of impact as my feild points).

good luck and let us know what you do?