what is the stock made out of. those three colors will all appear totally different, lighter or darker depending on the wood. for example i re-finished my 870 express after i cut the stock down w/ ebony because it is made of birch it didnt penetrate very well and ended up coming out a tick lighter then a jacobean color. still better then the origanal nasty color of the express line in my opinion.....test a small area under the barrel or behind the but platefirst and then decide thats what ide do.