I've shot both and didn't see a whole lot of difference in recoil between the two. If you devolop good shooting form,neither will be uncomfortable or uncontrollable to shoot. Both are comparable ballistically,recoil wise,and power wise. I believe both will be available for a long time so the decision all comes down to which rifle you prefer and personal choice as you won't go wrong with either. One main source of felt recoil isnot enougheye relief so be SURE and adjust accordingly to avoid "magnum eye".