for a body soap/ shampoo, deodorant, and clothing wash i use H.S. Scent-a-Way. For a clothing spay i use Scent Killer Autumn formula because it smells just like the area i hunt. Ive never tried the apple or pine scent. ive also used the ddw drier sheets. Been usingthese productsfor the past 4 years. Dont have any data to back it up but i have either killed a deer or let one pass under my stand every yearsince i began using it.