ORIGINAL: txjourneyman
Play for a 1/2 dozen arrows. The loser has to crest, cap, and fletch 6 arrows for the winner in the winners choice of brand, spine, color, and type of fletching. That way you get a personal touch while making the loser do some work. It will also be something the winner will likely respect and appreciate.
I like that idea. Unless it gets to costly.... Or maybe just a DLA Hat and something else small....