i dont know much about p&y but if it is based off of B&C then itsmaingoal is to honor the trophy, not the hunter.
I got a large deer this year (with a gun) but it was mostly luck. I talked with my dad about how tohunt our woods (all 2 acres) and went withhe suggested a spot that ialso thought about. I wenttoa tree that lookslike ait was lifted up and placed upside down. about Halftime of the OSU Michigan game,a deer came that we hadnt seen in a year. i am definately not the best hunter, and when my oppourtunity came, i took it.I'll admit my dadhelped me to get that deer but at the end of the day, it was me in that tree,not my dad, and i wouldwant nobody telling me that i dont deserve that deer or respect.
Everyone recieved help sometime in their hunting career. very few people went out in the woods with no knowledge about hunting. So by saying someone does not deserve respectbecause they had a guide helping them means that hardly anyone should get respect.
Overall, if you pulled the trigger, or released the arrow to get that deer, then good job and congrats.