I dont have a 357 lever rifle (yet) but i do have a marlin 1894 in 44 mag and my buddy has a winchester in 44 mag... IMHO i think the marlins a nicer rifle. I think the 44 mag would suit your purpose a little better than the 357. The 357 will work fine if thats what you choose. Its all a matter of personal preference. try both out and see what you like better if possable