I mean, how did he shoot 3 legally??? From every regulation I can read in NYS, you can only take 2 bucks, 1 in regular season, and 1 in either bow or muzzleloader season. If you take a buck in bow season, you must shoot an antlerless deer in muzzleloader. Please correct me if I wrong, but that is the way I read the regs, and what it says on my tags.