First of all, like Bob S said, this deer is only 1 1/2 years old. A deer that young could have about any kind of rack and still end up a really nice deer at 4 or 5 years old.

Secondly, geneticsare nearly impossible to manipulate in a free-ranging deer herd, so all you'd be doing is filling your tag with a small-racked, young deer. Let him get some age on him and fill your tag with an older deer if you've got a choice. Especially if he may get you fined. Spend that extra $25 on your girlfriend...or better yet, buy some new deer calls.