ORIGINAL: burniegoeasily
Lol. Id take the younger one regardless of rack. I hunt for the better meat. Just like this weekend. I had a couple of giant mud movers with great big tusks(boar hogs) in a field and a few smaller ones. I arrowed the smallest, a 150lber because the meat is better. But to each his own. As long as the meat is not wasted for a set of antlers.
My grampa is the same way, LOL
I put him on the biggest buck of his life 10 years ago, a button was with the buck. I said take'm Gramps, he shot the button[&:] I said "What in the heck did you do that for?" He looked at me "The little one's are better eating". I just smiled and pick his dog, oops deer up and drag him in.