When I run his numbers on the selection chart on www.bowjackson.comwith the info he has given, all he has to do to get on the list of recommended shafts is to drop 1 lb.of draw weight. Granted it is listed as medium stiffness, it is still there. I agree he is on the soft side for spine, but it may work OK. Now if he has majorissues with these arrows, he may have wasted some money.