I use neoprene boot foot waders. They are a little heavier and it's an extra seam that can leak. My next pair are going to be neoprene stocking foot. As far as neoprene vs. breathable, it depends on what kind of temperatures you'll be fishing in. If it's going to be pretty cold then I would go with neo. but if it's going to be warm (above 55 or so for me anyway) go with the breathable.