At a more reasonable price buying a deer like this to improve the gene pool on your farm wouldn't be a bad idea. The idea of shooting him is ridiculous, however. And before anyone says that relocating genes isn't a "natural" thing to do, keep in mind that most states int he US had to relocate deer in years past to re-establish deer herds and that our CURRENT deer population is hardly the original gene pool from a geographic standpoint.
I sure would like to have that deer's genes flowing all around where I hunt!