View Poll Results: A poll
Voters: 77. You may not vote on this poll
Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
#1
Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
I have been looking at a lot of big whitetail and mulie bucks on the net and in big Buck magazine ... I was wondering ... if you have the chance to hunt an area that provided both ...and if you had the opportunity to shoot a B&C animal which had you rather take and why...assuming either would be a trophy and the rack would be comprable in score ?
dd
dd
#2
RE: Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
I'd rather kill the whitetail. There is just something about them, plus I have never been mulie hunting before. Just don't seem the same to me.
Nothing against Mulies or mulie hunters.
Nothing against Mulies or mulie hunters.
#3
RE: Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
I would rather shoot the Mule Deer than the Whitetail....for the exact opposite reasons as GUS.
I can always shoot a Whitetail Buck....Wait a minute, I hunt NH.....nevermind!
I can always shoot a Whitetail Buck....Wait a minute, I hunt NH.....nevermind!
#4
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: mississippi by way of Florida
Posts: 357
RE: Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
Well,
I am with Jimmy. While B&C whitetails are rare in my area, a few do get taken every year. If I put that kind of money on the table to hunt, I think I would rather take the muley. Of course, if I saw one of each, being the basically greedy sob that I am, I would shoot the biggest (I know, you thought I was gonna say both, I ain't that greedy!)
R
Hank
I am with Jimmy. While B&C whitetails are rare in my area, a few do get taken every year. If I put that kind of money on the table to hunt, I think I would rather take the muley. Of course, if I saw one of each, being the basically greedy sob that I am, I would shoot the biggest (I know, you thought I was gonna say both, I ain't that greedy!)
R
Hank
#8
RE: Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
to me, whitetails are just better looking on the wall. being from the east, when i see someones big mulie deer head on the wall i think, "well he paid alot of money to harvest that animal" to where a B&C whitetail its like "wow did you get that around here?!"
#10
RE: Big Whitetail or Big Mule Deer
ORIGINAL: HuntinGUS
I'd rather kill the whitetail. There is just something about them, plus I have never been mulie hunting before. Just don't seem the same to me.
Nothing against Mulies or mulie hunters.
I'd rather kill the whitetail. There is just something about them, plus I have never been mulie hunting before. Just don't seem the same to me.
Nothing against Mulies or mulie hunters.