the HCC is better than all of those mentioned except maybe the muddy. The 3rd arm is a nice unit as well. See my post on your other thread, I've got both and am selling one of them, which ever one sells first, and I'll use the other one during the season.
I use the HCC hd, it works well..............I did however see a good one at a show called the Rock Steady by http://skipenterprises.com/, if i were buying a new one that is the one i would get.
Muddy hands down for as far as price and the ease of use!! Walt
__________________ www.whiteknuckleproductions.com
Elite Hunter in AT with snow limbs
Elite Archery Judge
Vital BowGear 5 pin sight
NAP Apache rest
Nap BloodRunners