H.S. Undertaker Vs. Primos tightwad

MOmightymite · 03-25-2008, 09:14 PM

My birthday is next week, and I'm asking for a turkey choke and narrowed it down to these mainly because of price. I know the undertakers are really good, but does anyone have any experience with the tightwad? I can get the undertaker at bass pro for $20, but I can get the primos tightwad for $20, and it comes with their turkey hunting dvd and paper targets. What do you guys think?

MOmightymite · 03-26-2008, 04:18 PM

No one can answer this for me? I guess I will buy them both and take one back after I shoot them.

superstrutter · 03-26-2008, 04:32 PM

Never used the tightwad. I do use the Jellyhead and really like it. I have taken several birds with an undertaker, but the Jellyhead patterns better.

Shawn Perkins · 03-26-2008, 04:53 PM

just bought a tightwad, its being shipped right now. it should be here within 5-10 days from bass pro, hopefully its better than my remington superfull i bought from my local store!!

turkeygirl2 · 03-26-2008, 06:37 PM

I use an Undertaker in my Mossberg 500 20 ga and for the price...does well. I wanted something better than a factory choke but not alot of money, and the Undertaker falls in that category.

Dr Andy · 03-27-2008, 06:15 AM

I have the undertaker on my Moss 500 and it's ok, not great but I can put 30 pellets (5's)on a 9" paper plate at 40yds and I don't want to shoot them farther away. Mine is for lead only, check if you can use hevi-shot in yours, (not that it matters a lot, having a lead only choke saves me money since I'm not tempted to buy expensive shells)

foxfire66 · 03-27-2008, 11:59 AM

This will be my 5th year using the Undertaker. I use it with my Mossberg835 ultra-mag. It patterns well for the price.

TN Deer Hunter · 03-27-2008, 01:47 PM

I shoot the undertaker in my 870 supermag and it does great with the Win. Supreme 5's. I shot a frederal Flight contrl through it today and it didn't pattern worth a damn.

Gobblinthunder · 03-27-2008, 07:35 PM

UNDERTAKER 100%-- with 12 ga.3"Winchester Supreme #5's Dropped lots of birds 50+ yds with it!never had a miss with it!!
Before i switched to H.S. STRUT Undertaker.i had unbelievable misses and dissapointments. a while back at a hunting shop i saw the undertaker and bought it and it is the best of the best!! a standard for turkey hunting.no one should shoot turkeys unless they are shooting through an undertaker...
lol thats how i feel about it.