two bucks from MN aging help

[mconwa951]

here are two that I have on camera i have 5 more from my property but they are all 1.5 olds for sure what do you think about these
The first I would think is 1.5 but has a filled out nose so thinking maybe 2.5 with small horns
the second I think is either 2.5 or 3.5 what are your thoughts

[penninside08]

id say both are 1.5 year olds come hunting season

[browningbolt]

both 1 1/2

[timmyzimmy]

each are 1 1/2. First one was prolly born later.

[Carbon_Slinger]

I agree with the rest. I see no muscle mass through their shoulders. The second picture though looks like he'll be a dandy in three or four years. Keep record of him through the years.

[mconwa951]

Ok I have 3 more bucks almost identical in size to this one I know these are all 1.5 years old I dont see how the second pic above can possible be a 1.5yr old

[OhioBowhunter]

2 yr old for second pic born late or mabey just small body but alot of antler growth so far

[RUNNOFT]

The second deer is only 1.5, and he is not that big for a 1.5. But then again the deer could be smaller in your area than most.

1.5 year old deer range in size just like 5 year olds... The main thing that I noticed from the picture is the lack of muscle definition that deer get as they get older. Carbon Slinger is %100 percent correct.

One last thing, to get a true answer, you need to show the pic to people that are familiar with the deer in the area.

[WIbuckchaser]

Most likely 1.5.