I would let him walk. He doesn't look old, so maybe next year he will be something much different. We had a button here last year, and this year he is a nice fork, not as nice as that, but still nice for his first antlers. If I didn't know it was the button, I wouldn't believe it myself, but his right ear is cut in a very distinct way, so I know he is the same deer. I couldn't believe he had the forks for a first set of antlers, especially here in NY. There are so many little spikes and tiny forks around here this year. I would have thought one of those were him, but there he was with his scarred ear and forks on his head. Anyway, I don't think you wanted all that for an answer, but I would let him walk one more year and see what happens. This was a button last year. Like I said, nothing like yours, but impressive to me for first antlers.
What should I DO?
