I agree (at least somewhat

) with ewolf. Adjust your rest back to center and then change to 125 gn tips and see what happens. If the tear gets better, you know your arrows are too stiff. Sounds like you're already pretty close to max on draw weight, so if the heavier tips don't fix it, you'll have to get different arrows. If it gets worse, you know your spine is too weak. If it's too weak, change to to lighter tips and/or reduce draw weight.
Also remember that paper tuning is as much a test of your shooting form as it is of bow tune. If you're torquing your grip, you'll never get a good hole in the paper.