Ive tried the Arizona, and didnt like it, the vanes seemed to stick to the jig. Ive gotta give another vote for the Bitzenberger, Ive used mine now for 14 years.
__________________
"Dont go leaving your ethics in the truck"
Switchback XT
Q2XL
Maxima Hunters
Onestringers wraps
Blazers
Muzzy 100 gr
__________________
"Minister of Information for the Royal Kingdom of $Tree"...
The common mistake people make when attempting to design something completely Idiot proof is to underestimate the ingenuity of complete Idiots.
The AZ does a good enough job and is very easy to use. Whatever you choose just make sure you don't use TOO MUCH glue.
Ditto on Kbacon's comment. I usually alternate between the AZ and a BPE Pro jig I have as well.
As for the fletchings sticking to the jig on the AZ....just dip the whole jig in acetone periodically (depending on use) and that problem tends to disappear.
We fletch with a 1 and 6 degree RH Arizona Fletcher. They work great. I think you will find that glue choice and arrow prep will have a greater impact on how well your fletching hold. Good luck!
I had a cheap $30 BPE jig and was satisfied with it. It was my first one so I didn't know what to expect. I ordered a Bitzenburger and was blown away. Certainly worth the extra $40. I would buy the Bitzenburger.