I agree........holy !@#$ I have never gotten tears that bad with any rest........much less my WB's !! [

]
Your still getting low tears and they seem to have changed from right to left .........although not as pronouced !!
Are you just eyeballing each set up ? Do you have them both set to the same center shot ? Which model WB do you have .....original,droptine, or deluxe ?
If you try the WB again ........lower it some and try going to the right a little ..........check it !! If it gets worse go to the left ! Once close.....with either rest........I'd start group tuning and then shooting broadheads !!