I can' t tell you whitch one is best, but I went and bought the New Shannon' s Bug Tamer about an hour ago. My local sporting goods store got some in and they will go fast down in Ga. I talked with several guys that has used them and they were very happy with the results. I also went to other message boards and asked the same question that you are asking. The majority of folks said to go with the bug tamer. The newest one has the no-see-um mesh on the outside and I like that. Also it is suppose to help control human scent. I guess the best way to test that will be when bow season opens in 4 weeks.