17 HMR: Savage or Marlin?

[slatecall]

I have decided to get a .17. Should I go with the savage or the marlin, in a heavy barrel. Another chioce is a used CZ American with a heavy barrel. Thanks

[johnch]

I say the Marlin with the new trigger , one badly out shot the Ruger I had.

[frizzellr]

I have a SAvage with the heavy barrel and while it shoots very well, I don't like the magazine release. It is just awkward and clumsy. The trigger also took some tweaking before it was acceptable, but for the money I guess I can't complain. I have no experience with the Marlin 17 HMR, but I have a 25MN in 22 Mag and I think it is a better rifle than the Savage.

[shootn hogs]

I love my marlin, it's a shooter. The finish on the stainless bull barrel scuffs up easily, but a little steel wool fixes this problem.

[trailer]

I have the Savage FVSS with the s/s bull barrel and it"™s a nice little gun. I don"™t have any problems with the clip although I"™ve had it for a couple of months and haven"™t shot it yet. The only reason I went with the Savage was because of the price. The Marlin is also a nice rifle. The clips holds more bullets and the barrel is 1"� longer. Other then that they are both good rifles.

[Highpower]

I have the Marlin with a heavy barrel. Good little shooter. Trigger is rough, but it'll shoot a quarter size group at 100 yards on a calm day. I figure if I could get the trigger cleaned up, it'll do better.

[TREEDOG]

Marlin vs 17 hmr here, tack driver deluxe. I wouldnt pass up a CZ if the price isnt bad!!!

[polack]

I have the Savage, good shooter terrible trigger.
Polack

[PABuck_HNTR]

My Marlin 17vs is a good shooter, a buddy has one of the Savage's and wishes he would have bought the Marlin

[Mr. Longbeard]

I have the savage At 50 yards about .25-.50 group 100 yards .50-.75 group