If you had a 30-06 and won a 270 would u keep it?
#1
Spike
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 63
If you had a 30-06 and won a 270 would u keep it?
I was at a gun drawing which I have never had luck at one before. Well I got lucky this time and won a 270 Ruger American. I like the rifle but I don't really know if I will use it. I have a Marlin XL7 in 30-06 that my wife gave me for our anniversary 3 years ago and I really love the rifle. I know its not a top of the line rifle but it shoots great and is very reliable hasn't let me down. I only use it for deer and coyotes. Does the 270 shoot that much flatter then a 30-06? I don't hunt in open country probably my longest shot is 100 yards at most. Plus I have deer hunted with a shot gun most my life and our area just went rifle 3 years ago so just about any rifle I use seems like a laser gun compared to my slug gun. I thought about trading both the ruger and marlin in on a tikka but I don't think I could give up the marlin cause of the sentimental value plus the wife would kill me. So that's outta the question. So my choices are to keep the ruger as a back up, or sell it or trade it in on a 50 cal muzzle loader cause I don't have one of those and it would expand my deer season. I just don't think I will get a lot for the ruger cause brand new there about 350.00 so im leaning towards just keeping it and switching off between the marlin and ruger.
#3
He said it already;
http://www.chuckhawks.com/perfect_pair.htm
Very little else does one really "need" !
.22 rimfire, if you got one .
http://www.chuckhawks.com/perfect_pair.htm
Very little else does one really "need" !
.22 rimfire, if you got one .
Last edited by Sheridan; 07-22-2014 at 06:20 PM.
#5
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 2,445
I can't see a scenario where getting a new rifle is a bad thing.
Hunting season starts tomorrow and you just found out your 30/06 has a problem of some sort. No big deal if you have a back-up rifle. Major headache if you don't.
Hunting season starts tomorrow and you just found out your 30/06 has a problem of some sort. No big deal if you have a back-up rifle. Major headache if you don't.
#7
"If you had a 30-06 and won a 270 would u keep it?"
That also happened to me a number of years ago, and I kept the .270. I worked up a load for it, but have never taken it hunting. It basically became a safe queen.
Like others posted, if you don't have a use for it, it might be best to trade it for something that you will shoot more.
That also happened to me a number of years ago, and I kept the .270. I worked up a load for it, but have never taken it hunting. It basically became a safe queen.
Like others posted, if you don't have a use for it, it might be best to trade it for something that you will shoot more.
#10
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: WY
Posts: 2,056
If I were to keep just one, I'd ditch the .270. Although there's nothing wrong with a .270, the very simple fact that your wife gave you the .30-06 to honor an important day with something she knew you'd like is a treasure unto itself. No such importance or significance is assigned to that .270.
But from a practical perspective, while the .270 is slightly flatter shooting, it's not so much flatter shooting that the .30-06 will be a liability. If you can't hit it with a .30-06, you're not going to hit it with the .270 either. You're limited in what the .270 will throw, while a .30-06 can chew through everything from 110 gr varmint bullets to 220 grain bone-crushers and everything in-between.
Were it me, I'd swap the .270 out for something in a different cartridge and game class. A .223 or a .243 would be first on my list. If you go bigger, you'd really have to start at the .338 WM to gain appreciably over the .30-06.
The .30-06 is a superb, all-around chambering. Your wife chose well.
But from a practical perspective, while the .270 is slightly flatter shooting, it's not so much flatter shooting that the .30-06 will be a liability. If you can't hit it with a .30-06, you're not going to hit it with the .270 either. You're limited in what the .270 will throw, while a .30-06 can chew through everything from 110 gr varmint bullets to 220 grain bone-crushers and everything in-between.
Were it me, I'd swap the .270 out for something in a different cartridge and game class. A .223 or a .243 would be first on my list. If you go bigger, you'd really have to start at the .338 WM to gain appreciably over the .30-06.
The .30-06 is a superb, all-around chambering. Your wife chose well.