S&W Ibolt must not be doing so well
#11
Giant Nontypical
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location:
Posts: 6,471
RE: S&W Icon must not be doing so well
What is the reason you wouldn't buy one? I bought the camo version in a 30-06 and it is one sweet rifle. I would like to hear any pros and cons about this rifle from others that have them or have shot them.
#12
RE: S&W Icon must not be doing so well
What is the reason you wouldn't buy one? I bought the camo version in a 30-06 and it is one sweet rifle. I would like to hear any pros and cons about this rifle from others that have them or have shot them
Bolt binds easilywhen worked, The searis the bolt stop, [:'(]getting the bolt in and out of the receiver is a PITA,fit and finish is not very good IMO, The stock is flimsy at best, The sling swivel studs are molded plastic and part of the stock itself.
For $300 they aren'tbad but definetly not worth much more than that IMHO.
I have never shot one so I couldn't sayhowaccurate they arebut from a design stand point there is a lot that could be improved upon.
#14
Giant Nontypical
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location:
Posts: 6,471
RE: S&W Icon must not be doing so well
I knew this was discussed a few months ago and you had some comment about the bolt stop...I worked the bolt on the one at Gander and didn't like the action either. But for 279 its cheaper then a 710 or 770 and 2x the rifle or more.
Bolt binds easilywhen worked, The searis the bolt stop, [:'(]getting the bolt in and out of the receiver is a PITA,fit and finish is not very good IMO, The stock is flimsy at best, The sling swivel studs are molded plastic and part of the stock itself.
#15
RE: S&W Icon must not be doing so well
Well reading those articles the rifle does seem to have some design issues. Seems plenty accurate enough though. Still, I think they may want to address the bolt removal design and the firing issue before I would consider buying one.
I would really hate it if the rifle didn't fire or the bolt locked up if I needed a second shot at a nice buck. (not that I'd ever need a second shot or anything)
I would really hate it if the rifle didn't fire or the bolt locked up if I needed a second shot at a nice buck. (not that I'd ever need a second shot or anything)
#18
RE: S&W Icon must not be doing so well
oldelkhunter and bigbulls, I just noticed that the both of you joined on 2/12/2003.
I'm sure a lot a people are glad oldelkhunter changed his signature and decided to hang around. 6000+ and still going!
I'm sure a lot a people are glad oldelkhunter changed his signature and decided to hang around. 6000+ and still going!
#19
Giant Nontypical
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location:
Posts: 6,471
RE: S&W Icon must not be doing so well
oldelkhunter and bigbulls, I just noticed that the both of you joined on 2/12/2003.
Actually both of us have been here longer but there was a database failure of some sort so we started fresh as daisys on 2/12/2003