it depends how its loaded, the 450 is in fact a 45/70 loaded to full potential, nothing more, if your rifle can handle the pressure you can exactly duplicate the 450 with a 45/70 and handloads. So in the same model rifle they are the same
RR
I agree. 45-70 is much more versatile if you don't handload. Lots of standard ammo available if you want to shoot lighter loads, Garrett and Buffalo Bore amongst others if you want to are going after heavier or dangerous game.....or like recoil.
Agreed, which leads to the versatility of the 45-70. I'm not aware of anyone loading the 450 Marlin in lighter loadsadequate for deer/bear, so you have to handload to get reduced recoil. Buy the 45-70.
I like the 45-70 for the fact you can get lighter loads for it off the shelf as mentioned in one of the above posts. You can also get full bore loads that will get close to 458 Win Mag factory loads. Either cartridge will take down anything you care to hunt in North America. I reload for the 45-70, but sometimes I get lazy and grab a box of the cowboy loads to plank with at the range which is something you can't do with the 450 Mar.
Wonderful responses all around so far. Thanx. I would like to further the discussion by mentioning the rifle would be used primarily as a beer rifle, as well a timber gun for whitetail and other cxp2 to cxp3 game. I also don't have the means or time to handload at this time, but will soon. I'm wondering what companies out there offer 45-70 that are not ported, or .450 that aren'tported well. I can handle a bit more energy on the shoulder versus hearing damage. I can't seem to find unported new rifles in either of these calibers-are there any?-Your feedback is appreciated.
Just don't go and shoot any of my beer. I like to have a cold one now and then. As for the .45-70 and bear - every bear I shot with my 45-70 never complained and in fact didn't say hardly anything in the bed of my pickup.
__________________ PLEASE NOTE THAT DUE TO THE RISING COST IN AMMO PRICES I WILL NO LONGER BE FIRING A WARNING SHOT.
A government big enough to give you everything you want is big enough to take away everything you have.
I'm not as good as I'm gonna get - but I'm better than I used to be. "Life without God is like an unsharpened pencil - it has no point."
45-70 v. .450 marlin
