Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
#21
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
Andeven the lowly 30-30 win has a flatter trajectory than a shotgun slug.
Rem data...
http://www.remington.com/products/ammunition/ballistics/shotshell_slug_loads.asp
#23
Nontypical Buck
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: MB.
Posts: 2,984
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
ORIGINAL: Rebel Hog
It depends where I would be hunting. If I'm hunting in thick swamps or heavy cover and my shots are going to be 20-25 yds, I use Sabots. If my shots are going to be 75yds or more, I use a rifle.
It depends where I would be hunting. If I'm hunting in thick swamps or heavy cover and my shots are going to be 20-25 yds, I use Sabots. If my shots are going to be 75yds or more, I use a rifle.
#24
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
ORIGINAL: stubblejumper
As I stated,the 30-30 has a flatter trajectory than the slug.
As I stated,the 30-30 has a flatter trajectory than the slug.
While I am too tired to do the exact conversions, it looks to me like the Remmington Core Lokts have virtually identical trajectory to the 30-30's out to that 150yd range....Possibly even flatter. (The Rem data has a 150yd zero, while the 30-30 data I am looking at is for a 100yd sight in, as I mentioned I have no interest in doing the full conversions, I think even a simple review of the charts will prove my point.)
While I know your comment only related to trajectory....Cleary, given the fact that both trajectories are almost identical, from a purely ballistics pespective, the Remington Core Loktsis a far superior choice tothe 30-30 delivering over 20% more energy at a distance of 100yds. (Recoil however is another issue however..)
#25
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
While I am too tired to do the exact conversions, it looks to me like the Remmington Core Lokts have virtually identical trajectory to the 30-30's out to that 150yd range....Possibly even flatter. (The Rem data has a 150yd zero, while the 30-30 data I am looking at is for a 100yd sight in, as I mentioned I have no interest in doing the full conversions, I think even a simple review of the charts will prove my point.)
slug +2.4" at 100yards for a 150 yard zero
30-30-150gr load +1.6" for a 150yard zero
Therefore the slug drops more from 100 yards to 150 yards.
#26
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
Being a slug shooter I would consider the .6" differencedrop between the 170gr 30-30, and the 385gr 12ga to be "virtually identical trajectories" for deer hunting performance. (I agree you are correct in the original statement, that the 30-30 is flatter).
More importantly, (at least for my own purposes). I would never sacrifice a 20%+ drop in energyin hopes of gaininga maximum trajectory difference of .6" on deer sized game.
However, I can understand how shooters that are accustomed to shooting at longer distances don't view the comparison in the same light.
More importantly, (at least for my own purposes). I would never sacrifice a 20%+ drop in energyin hopes of gaininga maximum trajectory difference of .6" on deer sized game.
However, I can understand how shooters that are accustomed to shooting at longer distances don't view the comparison in the same light.
#27
Giant Nontypical
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: fort mcmurray alberta canada
Posts: 5,667
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
I agree you are correct in the original statement, that the 30-30 is flatter
#29
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Upstate NY
Posts: 666
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
i currently will use both. it depends on where i hunt and the laws on what you can use and so on. if you are going to hunt somewhere where rifle is acceptable AND you have a potential shot of over 100 yards then go with a rifle. but, if you live somewhere where you are not going to get a shot over 100 yrds. then the possibilty of using a slug gun is there. i would prefer a rifle just because it is going to be more accurate and will leave a cleaner shot. as far as cal/gauge rifle id use a .270 bolt action and for slug id use a 12 gauge without a question.
#30
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location:
Posts: 1,813
RE: Shotgun Slug vs. Rifle
"If" i was given the choise of shooting a deer with a slug gun (you pick the ammo) or a properly loaded 30-30, (you pick the range) i wouldtake the 30-30 every time!
All of the medium power range of deer rifles out perform a 30-30, and they easily out perform a shot gun slug too. (if they are properly loaded) I just don't understand why someone who can hunt with a rifle, and owns both firearms, would pick a slugfor close range and a rifle for further out.
The rifle will work at both ranges, it's the obvious choise.
Drilling Man
All of the medium power range of deer rifles out perform a 30-30, and they easily out perform a shot gun slug too. (if they are properly loaded) I just don't understand why someone who can hunt with a rifle, and owns both firearms, would pick a slugfor close range and a rifle for further out.
The rifle will work at both ranges, it's the obvious choise.
Drilling Man