In a 17 HMR is there going to be that much of an accuracy difference between a semi and bolt action? There are a couple bolt actions that i really like and a semi that i really like to. the bolt actions are the marlin, the savage(w/ thumbhole stock) and the semi is the remington 597.
__________________
SEMPER FI, HUNT UNTIL YOU DIE!
NAHC LIFE MEMBER
WILDLIFE FOREVER MEMBER
Usually the bolt action will be more accurate. Honestly though it could be a toss up especially in the rimfire world. There are some guys with Ruger 10-22s(and 10/17s)that shoot awesome.(Im sure other semi's also). I would go shoulder the rifles you are looking at dry fire them a couple times to see how much trigger you are dealing with and then going from there. Seems like in the rimfire auto's that individual rifles are more accurate then others of the same make more ofter then in larger centerfire guns. That may just because almost everyone has the rimfire stuff so its east to compare also.
To answer you question the bolt will prob be a little more accurate but theres a chance that 597 will outshoot both of the bolt your looking at also.
__________________
"What do you mean I ain't kind? Just not your kind."
First thing first. Forget about the 597. One of the worst designed rim fires Remington has made. Yes I speak from my own experience as well as other people that I know that have them.
I would definetly choose the Savage BTVS over the others. This gun should prove to be a highly accurate little 17.
__________________
"The danger to America is not Barack Obama but a citizenry capable of entrusting a man like him with the Presidency........... Blaming the prince of the fools should not blind anyone to the vast confederacy of fools that made him their prince. The Republic can survive a Barack Obama, who is, after all, merely a fool. It is less likely to survive a multitude of fools such as those who made him their president."
If you want to try the trigger in the store, go armed with a handful of snap caps (if they make them in 17)so you don't dammage the firing pins.
__________________ http://www.illinoisbowfishers.com
The truest measure of a man's ethics is what he does when no one is watching. -God
An unarmed man can only flee from Evil, and Evil is not overcome by fleeing from it.
- Colonel Jeff Cooper
I see guys crying about there 597's, but all i can tell you is this. I bought a new 597M several years ago, and to this day it has NOT jammed or failed to function in any way!
Yeaaaa i know, every time i have good luck with a firearm around here, i'm always the "luckiest" guy here to own one...
I think the 597 magazine problems are pretty much taken care of on the "later guns"... I guess i'll wait around for someone to come along and say i'm full of it!!!
The Marlins are the guns to beat. Those little guns are second to none in the accuracy department. If the tax man sees fit to give me a return, I may be owning one.
__________________
You may beat the rap, but you won't beat the ride!
After numerous complaints we have finally got the mag problems worked out on the 597's .we put out approx.500 to 600 of theses guns chambered for the 17 cal. a week and i must say that the 17 cal. is one the better shooting guns gpoup wise that we manufacture whether it be for target shooting or small game.
__________________
I'M NOT JUS YER PLAIN OL' REDNECK, I'M A KENTUCKY REDNECK
The savage and the marlins both shoot about the same for the money, very well! It realy just boils down to which looks better. The nodd goes to savage for me though because you can get it with the accutrigger now. I think in most cases it will function better and be more accurate than the remington. Just my opinion though.
I have a savage heavy barrel I paid 200 bucks for and love it.
Paul
__________________
I didn't climb to the top of the food chain to eat carrots! (Ron White)
semi vs. bolt action
about there 597's, but all i can tell you is this. I bought a new 597M several years ago, and to this day it has NOT jammed or failed to function in any way!
