Since I am looking into getting a handicapped permit to use a crossbow, and the Advisory Commitee found out, I have been tasked with writing a new proposal to send to the Game Board, for crossbows to use here in Alaska. I know very little about crossbows, and have only used vertical archery equipment.
The animals we hunt range from foxes to Brown Bears. Now I know my little 45# recurve will take a Black Bear, Wolf, or a Caribou. But I don't want to use it for Moose or Grizzly Bears. Let alone those big monster Brown Bears down on the coast. So I don't expect a one size fits all here. What I need is info on what you guys would use to hunt these animals. Also conditions in Alaska is far differant from hunting in the lower 48.
Seems I read somewhere a few years ago that you needed a minimum of 350FPS to hunt Grizzly or Brown Bears. Can't remember where I read that. For the average Moose in Alaska think of the biggest Elk you ever saw on steroids. The big boys are even bigger, think of a Clysdale.
If we make Crossbows legal, the general public is going to use them for everything they can. We don't need to have some guy go out with an inadiquate crossbow and after shooting a bolt into a Brown Bear, getting eaten.
Also aiming or sighting devices. Peep site, Red dots, Non-Magnification Scopes, or full blown Scopes. Which would be best? All info would be appreciated.
While velocity (fps) may be a readily enforceable standard, I personally feel the kinetic energy is a better measure for what it takes to kill an animal, esp of the size specified. IMO, while less can get it done, 100# KE is required to harvest deer humanely. I'd want at least that much for moose and significantly more for brown bear.
As for sights, I would not put any limitations on use of same. Given that any archery is a close up endeavor, a magnifying scope won't make any difference as to how far an archer can shoot. It would seem that accurate shooting is not just desirable but essential here. Most quality crossbow scopes now have multiple aim points on their reticule, whose spacing can be varied-by changing the magnification-to match the arrow's trajectory, thus they can definitely make a big difference to precise arrow placement over open sights, non-magnifying scopes or red dots or reflex sights.
__________________
Vortex, Phoenix, Cyclone, single shot rifles and handguns.
Only accurate guns- and bows - are interesting.
I checked several sources and here is the chart they give for ther energy needed to take certain game. Just remember the longer the shot the slower the arrow is going which lowers the K/E. Personally I would want the hardest hitting for most game in case the shot isnt perfect.
Recommended Arrow Energy For Bow Hunting
25 ft. lbs. Small Game
25-41 ft. lbs. Medium Game (Deer, Antelope)
42-65 ft. lbs. Large Game (Elk, Black Bear, Wild Boar)
65 ft. lbs. Toughest Game (Cape Buffalo, Grizzly)
I checked several sources and here is the chart they give for ther energy needed to take certain game. Just remember the longer the shot the slower the arrow is going which lowers the K/E. Personally I would want the hardest hitting for most game in case the shot isnt perfect.
Recommended Arrow Energy For Bow Hunting
25 ft. lbs. Small Game
25-41 ft. lbs. Medium Game (Deer, Antelope) 42-65 ft. lbs. Large Game (Elk, Black Bear, Wild Boar)
65 ft. lbs. Toughest Game (Cape Buffalo, Grizzly)
You first.
__________________
Vortex, Phoenix, Cyclone, single shot rifles and handguns.
Only accurate guns- and bows - are interesting.
Thats why I said " I personally like more" for any distance and the not perfect hit. Most know I like a fast hard hitting bow which translate to lots of K/E. We are fortunate, in the days of traditional archery there was not much choice. I will take 100 plus for all game deer and larger. I was just posting what the "professionals" say.
Charts don't mean squat!! Get the advice of an experienced crossbow hunter who has actually taken critters the size of buffalo, moose and African Game . Following the advice of somebody who has done nothing but sat behind a computer, pretending to be an expert is not the way to go.
I sugguest you contact Bill Trobridge , the President and Owner of Excalibur Crossbows. He has taken many large animals up to and including an elephant, I'm sure hw will be glad to pass on his recommendations to you. They will definitely be valid recommendations.
You can contact him through the Excalibur Website or forum
Charts don't mean squat!! Get the advice of an experienced crossbow hunter who has actually taken critters the size of buffalo, moose and African Game . Following the advice of somebody who has done nothing but sat behind a computer, pretending to be an expert is not the way to go.
I sugguest you contact Bill Trobridge , the President and Owner of Excalibur Crossbows. He has taken many large animals up to and including an elephant, I'm sure hw will be glad to pass on his recommendations to you. They will definitely be valid recommendations.
You can contact him through the Excalibur Website or forum
Again this is why I like a fast hard hitting bow thats rated about 100 K/E. So many want to know what the experts say, thats there chart not mine.
Another vote for k.e. rather than equipment limits. The elephant mentioned above was taken w/ 900 gr arrow at about 250 fps for about 125 # k.e. Same guy took two moose w/ a 150# Vixen at a k.e. of about 67, and I shot a 1000 3 cow buff, cut rib in two off side, 446 gr arrow at 290ish for 83# k.e. My bhead was a slick trick Mag, elephant was two blade, can't help on rest. Good luck!
I'm confidant my buff rig would kill one of your bears graveyard dead if I took the shot I'd wait for.
Another vote for k.e. rather than equipment limits. The elephant mentioned above was taken w/ 900 gr arrow at about 250 fps for about 125 # k.e. Same guy took two moose w/ a 150# Vixen at a k.e. of about 67, and I shot a 1000 3 cow buff, cut rib in two off side, 446 gr arrow at 290ish for 83# k.e. My bhead was a slick trick Mag, elephant was two blade, can't help on rest. Good luck!
I'm confidant my buff rig would kill one of your bears graveyard dead if I took the shot I'd wait for.
Agreed, like I say a fast hard hitting bow, faster allows for a larger broadhead if needed to get the extra K/E.
Crossbows For Moose And Brown Bears
