I can tell you one thing Jeff, I better play the wind right this morning (SSW at 4-5) because by the time I knew it this morning, I had already showered with my regular dove soap! I was on autopilot in the shower, my body ready to go to work instead of into the woods...we shall see if I put on a dove soap deer drive heading in here in a few minutes.
I feel less wind is actually worse. It lets your scent pool more and doesn't disperse it near as much as a stiff breeze does. Sometimes you just gotta take your chances. Maybe the deer will show up on your good side anyways.
And it wouldn't be the first time a weather person missed the forcast!!!
Don't quite know what u mean, but I always hunt with the wind direction in my favor regardless of speed. Too windy of a day such as 25-30 mph winds seem to make the deer set tight most of the time...takes away their ability to hear. Better off staying home on a day like that
I'm no "Wind diehard" but I always thought wind was wind when talking about deer hunting, be it 1MPH or 10MPH. However, I don't let an unfavorable wind keep me at home. I've had success several times while deer have been downwind of me. Sometimesyou just have to trust your scent control.
__________________
Give 'em the shaft, walk the red path, and grab life by the antlers - Me
5 or 20 mph. Either one Is a "no no" In my book If It's not a good wind direction. If you keep hunting the wind like you are I think In time you won't even ask yourself this question anymore. I just get pissed when the winds bad, there's nothing more I can do about It.
I'll put it this way... I'm heading out this afternoon after a buck I've got on trail cam that's got a huge sticker coming off his right G2; I've always wanted a "sticker" buck. I saw exactly where he came out two nights ago, and I'll be set up there by 4 this afternoon because I've gota perfect North wind to do so.
If the wind was even blowing ONE mile per hour South this afternoon, I would NOT be hanging there. So I guess there's your answer... from at least one die-hard wind player.
I"™m getting real tired of this wind dictating where I hunt deal (for my own personal enjoyment). If I have a steady forecasted wind of over 7-8 mph, I"™ll try to play it. But when I get these dinky little "ślight & variable"ť or 5 mph & less, I am going to hunt where I want, and think the deer will be. I"™ll let my scent control take over from there. I had the "śwrong"ť wind for my Saturday morning hunt, but that was the only area with deer sign & I hadn"™t seen a thing playing the "śright"ť winds. I went there, saw deer directly downwind, they came in and I killed one. This ain"™t the first time (killing a deer down wind), and it won"™t be the last.
__________________
Just a regular guy who likes to hunt