Upon further inspection... Im not 100% sure anymore.

[buckmaster]

Ok guys, I thought I knew what i was talking about but probably not. Ok so I was looking at the rest of my 2007 pics of my deer, and found this small 8 pointer that looks to the perfect amount of growth to the 10pnt I have this year. I really thought it was the Big 8 from '07 Just got more points but smaller... IDK

What do you guys think?? Same deer? Take 3.

THeres no question about "Rob".


2007















2008
















Just in case you missed my last post

http://www.huntingnet.com/forum/tm.aspx?m=2984589&mpage=1&key==

[Bullet Hole Bailey]

Its hard tellin because who knows if he hung around or if one of his brothers moved in with teh same genetics or something.

But who cares....theyre big bucks!

[buckmaster]

I mean what are the odds of the 2 SAME deer, being in the same EXACT place, EXACTLY 365days later?

[2 Lunger]

Same deer! Look at the dates in the pics. He's in hard antler at the same time each year. Nice post Buckmaster!

[buckmaster]

Yes 2 Lunger... but what about the 8pnt in 2007 and the 10pnt in 2008?

[OKbowhunter20]

ORIGINAL: buckmaster

I mean what are the odds of the 2 SAME deer, being in the same EXACT place, EXACTLY 365days later?

If this is true, that is one heck of a pattern

[bloodcrick]

Im just amazed they are in hard antler. mine are still fuzzys []

[2 Lunger]

ORIGINAL: buckmaster

Yes 2 Lunger... but what about the 8pnt in 2007 and the 10pnt in 2008?

The freak deer is definantely the same deer. Its hard to tell about the other deer. I don't see why not it couldn't be him. These bucks may all bach. up with each other every year.

[GMMAT]

I mean what are the odds of the 2 SAME deer, being in the same EXACT place, EXACTLY 365days later?

Got me beat. My SAME deer was in the EXACT same place......EXACT same pose.....366 days later.

[thehairlessone!]

i would guess the same deer but who knows. Shoot him anyways!

rick