Mature buck "Age structure" the "Great Equalizer"?

[GMMAT]

I find it fascinating that people who claim to be "mature buck" hunters would forego a "more" mature animal.......for one with more rack size....but who is less "mature" in age structure. I'm not condemning the practice.....just saying I find it "fascinating".

"Might" the reason for this be......that "age structure" is the "great equalizer" when it comes to hunting "mature bucks"?

I mean.....a man in FL can target 3.5+yr old deer ......and in his mind.....he's leveled the playing field withhis compadrefrom IL.

Does this "leveling" of the playing field rub "some" the wrong way?

Curious at to your thoughts on this.

[BowHuntingFool]

ORIGINAL: GMMAT

I find it fascinating that people who claim to be "mature buck" hunters would forego a "more" mature animal.......for one with more rack size....but who is less "mature" in age structure.Â* I'm not condemning the practice.....just saying I find it "fascinating".

"Might" the reason for this be......that "age structure" is the "great equalizer" when it comes to hunting "mature bucks"?

I mean.....a man in FL can target 3.5+yr old deer ......and in his mind.....he's leveled the playing field withÂ*his compadreÂ*from IL.

Does this "leveling" of the playing field rub "some" the wrong way?

Curious at to your thoughts on this.

WHoa.....That is kinda hard to read with all of the "____" on every other word! I caught "myself" reading it the way "Chandler Bing" from TV show "Friends" talks! LOL!

[GMMAT]

Don't hate me because I can punctuate, BHF (find another reason).

And you watched that show?

Hand over the man card.[8D]

[early in]

ORIGINAL: BowHuntingFool

WHoa.....That is kinda hard to read with all of the "____" on every other word! I caught "myself" reading it the way "Chandler Bing" from TV show "Friends" talks! LOL!

GMMAT does that so you don't get it "twisted" or "spun".

[GMMAT]

If you're really that petty that you have to stoop to this......please just refrain from posting on my threads.

Please.

[Germ]

Well "W" "T" "F"

It's the entire look, not just the rack

[GMMAT]

I mean.....a man in FL can target 3.5+yr old deer ......and in his mind.....he's leveled the playing field withhis compadrefrom IL.

Does this "leveling" of the playing field rub "some" the wrong way?

You still havent answered (or in some cases, attempted to) the question.

[Double Creek]

I would think in the 1 buck states, a lot of hunters want a mature deer AND a high score..... And by passing a mature deer with a low score may give them that chance.....

I've passed several mature bucks that didn't have squat for score on properties where I'm only allowed one buck... I did that b/c I know there is a good chance I can kill a deer with both attributes.....

[TexasBowHunter]

The property thatI hunt, it is at least a4 1/2yo regardless of what is on his head!!!! Thats the name of the game there, I knew it when I opted to lease the place and that is the way it will be, regardless if it is a 110" 4 1/2yo or a 140" 4 1/2yo.....They are both shooters on our place, I had a hard time last year passing a high 130's 3 1/2yo (would be the best deer I have shot to date) but in a couple years it will be worth letting him go.

If I was hunting a different place my standards would be different I am sure but I chose to hunt this place!!!

[HuntingBry]

ORIGINAL: GMMAT

If you're really that petty that you have to stoop to this......please just refrain from posting on my threads.

Please.

Last I checked the threads belong to HNI, so they belong to all of us.[8D]

To your point, I honestly don't believe that the hunter in FL is hunting on the same playing field as the hunter in IL if they are both hunting 3.5 year old deer. The reason for that is in FL there is far lesshospitable habitat to support whitetailsland and the bag limits are incredibly liberal (a buck a day last I checked). Whereas in IL the habitat is much more conducive to holding and supporting whitetails and the bag limits are far more stringent allowing for more 3.5 year olds to grow.

That doesn't make the 3.5 year old buck any less difficult to hunt, but you have more opportunity to trip one up if there are more of them around.