Results from last season Broadhead Success Survey

[Cougar Mag]

2nd time I type this as my computer froze up this morning[:@]. Anyway, this was what was reported as successful while bowhunting this past season. Game animals reported taken were Whitetail, Blacktail, Black Bear, Mule Deer, Hogs(feral and Russian), Coyote, Caribou, Turkey, Antelope, Elk, Javalina(Txjourneyman)and Bobcat. Thanks to everyone taking the time to report the broadhead they used on each animal taken.

Listings are in order of brand total used. Brand in red used the most. Particular model in red used the most:

252 fixed blade heads(including cut-on-contact)
167 mechanical heads*denotes mechanical

Muzzy ............................................83
100 grain 3 blade................................51
125 gr. 3 blade 12
MX-3, 100 gr 5
100 gr. 4 blade 4
MX-4, 100 gr. 3
115 gr., 4 blade3
75 gr. 2
Phantom 220 gr. 2
Phantom 125 gr. 1

Rage.............................................. ....69
*2 blade, 100 gr.54
*3 blade, 100 gr.15

NAP(New Archery Products).................64
*Spitfire & Spitfire XP, 100 gr. 16
Hellrazor 100 gr. 11
Nitron 100 gr.9
Thunderhead 100 gr. 7
Thunderhead 125 gr.5
*Spitfire & Spitfire XP, 125 gr.4
*Shockwave 100 gr.3
Crossfire, 100 gr. 3
Thunderhead 85 gr.2
Razorcap 100 gr.2
*Gobbler Getter 100 gr.2

G5................................................ .........55
Montec 100 gr.24
Striker 100 gr.20
*Tekan II 100 gr.4
Montec 125 gr.2
Montec 85 gr.2
*Tekan 100 gr.1

Slicktrick........................................ .........37
Magnum 100 gr.17
Magnum 125 gr.10
Standard 100 gr.8
85 gr.2

Trophy Ridge(Rocket)................................27
*Hammerhead 100 gr.9
*Steelhead 100 gr.6
*Steelhead 125 gr.3
Ultimate Steel 100 gr.3
*Sidewinder 100 gr.3
*Wolverine 75 gr.2
*Strictnine 125 gr.1

Rocky Mountain.......................................... .20
*Snyper, 2 & 3 blade 100 gr.12
Turbo(Blitz) 100 gr.3
*Gator XP2
Ironhead 100 gr.2
Ironhead 125 gr.1

Grim Reaper............................................ ......16
*Razortip 100 gr.10
*Razorcut 100 gr.6

Magnus............................................ .............10
Stinger 2 blade 100 gr.5
Stinger w/bleeder blades 100 gr.1
Stinger Buzzcut 100 gr.2
Snuffer 125 gr.2

WASP.............................................. ..............10
Hammer SST 85 gr.4
*Jackhammer SST 100 gr.3
Boss 100 gr.2
Boss Bullet 100 gr.1

Crimson Talon............................................. ...7
*Talon XT100 gr.4
*Cuda 100 gr.2
*Raptor 100 gr.1

Tight Point ShuttleT-Lock................................4
100 gr.4

Aftershock........................................ ..............3
Maniac 100 gr. 2
*Hypershock 100 gr.1

*Piston Point 100 gr. .......................................3

German Kinetic Silver Flame 150 gr...................2

American Broadhead Company.........................2
Sonic 125 gr.1
Sonic 100 gr.1

Steelforce........................................ ................2
Phathead 100 gr.1
Sabertooth851

Satellite 100 gr. 2

Innerlock 100 gr.1
Game Tracker 100 gr.1
Eastman 100 gr.1
Wacem Triton 100 gr.1
ADS Gobbler Guillotine 100 gr.1
Allen Lightning 100 gr.1

[Schultzy]

Wow! I was the only one to use a Magnus Snuffer on this board. Good job Cougar and thanks for the results, its neat info seeing what everyone uses!

[GR8atta2d]

Wow as always Cougar Great job. We appreciate the hours and hours it takes to compile these results. It really speaks volumes for the many options available to fit every budget and application.

It would be cool if everyone of those wounded threads we see..would post the head and do a similiar spreadsheet. That too, might speak volumes.

[Rob/PA Bowyer]

ORIGINAL: Cougar Mag



Muzzy ............................................83
100 grain 3 blade................................51
125 gr. 3 blade 12
MX-3, 100 gr 5
100 gr. 4 blade 4
MX-4, 100 gr. 3
115 gr., 4 blade3
75 gr. 2
Phantom 220 gr. 2
Phantom 125 gr. 1

Rage.............................................. ....69
*2 blade, 100 gr.54
*3 blade, 100 gr.15

NAP(New Archery Products).................64
*Spitfire & Spitfire XP, 100 gr. 16
Hellrazor 100 gr. 11
Nitron 100 gr.9
Thunderhead 100 gr. 7
Thunderhead 125 gr.5
*Spitfire & Spitfire XP, 125 gr.4
*Shockwave 100 gr.3
Crossfire, 100 gr. 3
Thunderhead 85 gr.2
Razorcap 100 gr.2
*Gobbler Getter 100 gr.2

G5................................................ .........55
Montec 100 gr.24
Striker 100 gr.20
*Tekan II 100 gr.4
Montec 125 gr.2
Montec 85 gr.2
*Tekan 100 gr.1

Slicktrick........................................ .........37
Magnum 100 gr.17
Magnum 125 gr.10
Standard 100 gr.8
85 gr.2

Trophy Ridge(Rocket)................................27
*Hammerhead 100 gr.9
*Steelhead 100 gr.6
*Steelhead 125 gr.3
Ultimate Steel 100 gr.3
*Sidewinder 100 gr.3
*Wolverine 75 gr.2
*Strictnine 125 gr.1

Rocky Mountain.......................................... .20
*Snyper, 2 & 3 blade 100 gr.12
Turbo(Blitz) 100 gr.3
*Gator XP2
Ironhead 100 gr.2
Ironhead 125 gr.1

Grim Reaper............................................ ......16
*Razortip 100 gr.10
*Razorcut 100 gr.6

Magnus............................................ .............10
Stinger 2 blade 100 gr.5
Stinger w/bleeder blades 100 gr.1
Stinger Buzzcut 100 gr.2
Snuffer 125 gr.2

WASP.............................................. ..............10
Hammer SST 85 gr.4
*Jackhammer SST 100 gr.3
Boss 100 gr.2
Boss Bullet 100 gr.1

Crimson Talon............................................. ...7
*Talon XT100 gr.4
*Cuda 100 gr.2
*Raptor 100 gr.1

Tight Point ShuttleT-Lock................................4
100 gr.4

Aftershock........................................ ..............3
*Maniac 100 gr.2
*Hypershock 100 gr.1

*Piston Point 100 gr. .......................................3

German Kinetic Silver Flame 150 gr...................2

American Broadhead Company.........................2
Sonic 125 gr.1
Sonic 100 gr.1

Steelforce........................................ ................2
Phathead 100 gr.1
Sabertooth851

Satellite 100 gr. 2

Innerlock 100 gr.1
Game Tracker 100 gr.1
Eastman 100 gr.1
Wacem Triton 100 gr.1
ADS Gobbler Guillotine 100 gr.1
Allen Lightning 100 gr.1

I'm quite in the minority but that's okay, Rocky Mountain Snypers have proven themselves time and time again for me.


And CM, I want to personally thank you for taking the time to do this, especially since your computer froze up. [:@] [8D]

[Cougar Mag]

ORIGINAL: Schultzy

Wow! I was the only one to use a Magnus Snuffer on this board.

Shultzy, no I highly doubt you were the only one on this board to use Magnus Snuffer. Butyou were the only one who reported a kill(s) using it. Some members didn't post on the thread. GregH deleted his, _Dan never posted, Iamyourhuckaberry, lots of others I imagine.

Rob, thank you. Its nothing compared to what you do running the bowhunting contest..........now that's work! You are right, personally if I ever try a mechanical the RN Snyper would probably be first. Heck I am the only one to post using the RM Turbos and I've had nothing but great success using it.

GR8atta2d, I seriously think about an unsuccessful survery thread every season but not sureI should. If we could learn from it I think it would be great.

[MECHDOC]

Great post thanks.I am really not surprised that Muzzys are on top.They are a veryreliable and affordable broadhead.

[Schultzy]

ORIGINAL: MECHDOC

Great post thanks.I am really not surprised that Muzzys are on top.They are a veryreliable and affordable broadhead.

Years back they were very expensive when they first came out, what do they run now?

[Hunter Dan7]

thanks. sorry you had problems with your computer

[MECHDOC]

Muzzy are around 23 bucks for 6.Shop around ebay etc. youll be amazed at the prices.If you dontbuy the camo ones you will save alot more.

[mobow]

Coug......Thanks so much for doing this again....I don't know why I am so fascinated by this, but I am....Thanks for the efforts bud.