Are you shooting a flintlock with open sights?? Or an inline with a scope???
How far away can you keep all your shots in a 4 inch circle...
This needs to be addressed before recommendations can be made...
With my .54 caliber flintlock, I'm good to 100-125 yards...Plenty far for hunting in the woods...
In the evening, when deer hit the field 15 minutes after sundown, I have problems seeing the front sight...
With my scoped inline, I consider 150 yards my max range...
So for ME...I like to be within 75 yards with my flintlockand setup nearer the bedding area so I have good shooting light...
Hunting over soybeans, in the evening, I prefer the inline (or the .243)...