shoot or wait for friends to arrive
11-21-2015, 05:51 AM
#1
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: ONTARIO
Posts: 128
shoot or wait for friends to arrive
This happened to four people I know at a fly in.
The first person flew in with the gear. While the others were being picked up, the first person saw a moose and dropped it while waiting for the others to arrive. I think he shot from the dock. The other three were mad since the hunt was over before they landed, after paying $3000 each.
Do you think he should have waited so they can start the hunt together, or take a moose while the opportunity is there?
The first person flew in with the gear. While the others were being picked up, the first person saw a moose and dropped it while waiting for the others to arrive. I think he shot from the dock. The other three were mad since the hunt was over before they landed, after paying $3000 each.
Do you think he should have waited so they can start the hunt together, or take a moose while the opportunity is there?
11-21-2015, 07:09 AM
#4
Boone & Crockett
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: south eastern PA
Posts: 15,436
This doesn't pass the sniff test. Who in their right mind would pay 3 grand to hunt with three other hunters who also paid 3 grand and the hunt is over when the first animal hits the ground? Were they going to be angry at the guy who killed a moose if they were at in camp when it was killed and they were now done hunting? How were they going to decide who got to kill a moose? If this is a true situation, and I have serious doubts there are 4 people that dumb in one place even in Canada,
that guy paid the same amount as the others to hunt, he saw a moose and it was legal to shoot it, it may have been the only moose seen during the hunt, he was in the right place at the right time and he got lucky and killed it. Unless they had some kind of agreement about a shooting order I can't fault him.
that guy paid the same amount as the others to hunt, he saw a moose and it was legal to shoot it, it may have been the only moose seen during the hunt, he was in the right place at the right time and he got lucky and killed it. Unless they had some kind of agreement about a shooting order I can't fault him.
Last edited by Oldtimr; 11-21-2015 at 07:18 AM.
11-21-2015, 07:12 AM
#5
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: idaho
Posts: 2,773
yep . doesn't make sense to me. why wouldn't the others have a tag of their own? 12000 for one moose, IT IS BEYOND MY COMPREHENSION AS TO WHY ANYONE WOULD PAY THAT MUCH.
IF OTHERS DO HAVE TAG THE LUCKYGUY THAT SCORED GETS TO BECOME CAMP TENDER and cook some moose for the others dinner . so ,I don't see why they would be upset.
methinks we need more info.
IF OTHERS DO HAVE TAG THE LUCKYGUY THAT SCORED GETS TO BECOME CAMP TENDER and cook some moose for the others dinner . so ,I don't see why they would be upset.
methinks we need more info.
11-21-2015, 07:14 AM
#6
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: ONTARIO
Posts: 128
Maybe I got some of the facts wrong. The three grand may include travel north, food and drinks, as well as the outfitter cost. That was the number they were going on about.
Either way, out of curiosity, I am still undecided if I would take the shot if I was in that position.
I would probably wait if it were me.
They usually produce only every second year from that outfitter. Some years these four older guys pay to go a second time in the same year. These guys got the money so it is most likely really nice accommodations.
Either way, out of curiosity, I am still undecided if I would take the shot if I was in that position.
I would probably wait if it were me.
They usually produce only every second year from that outfitter. Some years these four older guys pay to go a second time in the same year. These guys got the money so it is most likely really nice accommodations.
11-21-2015, 07:27 AM
#7
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: idaho
Posts: 2,773
Maybe I got some of the facts wrong. The three grand may include travel north, food and drinks, as well as the outfitter cost. That was the number they were going on about.
Either way, out of curiosity, I am still undecided if I would take the shot if I was in that position.
I would probably wait if it were me.
They usually produce only every second year from that outfitter. Some years these four older guys pay to go a second time in the same year. These guys got the money so it is most likely really nice accommodations.
Either way, out of curiosity, I am still undecided if I would take the shot if I was in that position.
I would probably wait if it were me.
They usually produce only every second year from that outfitter. Some years these four older guys pay to go a second time in the same year. These guys got the money so it is most likely really nice accommodations.
I'M being silly ,of coarse. like I said .we need more info. whole situation doesn't make sense.
11-21-2015, 07:44 AM
#8
Fork Horn
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: ONTARIO
Posts: 128
I never used an outfitter myself, but learning that you usually get more than one adult tag, the others are probably just jealous that they got skunked.
If they have more than one adult tag, then I would shoot for a good start.
I do have other friends that moose hunt with an outfitter. They get one bull and one cow tag from the outfitter. So getting only one bull tag didn't sound unusual.
When I see one of them again, I will ask the question on how many tags are included (other than the automatic calf). That would be the decider if I would shoot.
If they have more than one adult tag, then I would shoot for a good start.
I do have other friends that moose hunt with an outfitter. They get one bull and one cow tag from the outfitter. So getting only one bull tag didn't sound unusual.
When I see one of them again, I will ask the question on how many tags are included (other than the automatic calf). That would be the decider if I would shoot.